The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping received sharply divided reviews on November 17, ahead of its November 20 theatrical release: Polygon ranks it among the franchise’s best, while Deadline sees a series running short on momentum. Haymitch’s return has given critics plenty to argue about.
According to Variety, Francis Lawrence’s latest adaptation of Suzanne Collins’ work follows 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada, through the 50th Hunger Games. Set 24 years before the original film, it revisits the character audiences first met through Woody Harrelson.
For longtime fans, the question is whether knowing Haymitch’s future makes this trip more compelling. The reviews offer very different answers, with critics weighing the emotional cost of his story against another round of familiar franchise rituals.
A Tragedy or Another Lap Around the Arena?
For Polygon, that familiar destination becomes the film’s strength. Its review reads Sunrise on the Reaping as horror built around mounting loss, with Zada carrying an increasingly painful story. The colorful arena and its lethal wildlife contribute to a sense that danger can come from anywhere.
Deadline reaches almost the opposite conclusion about that setting. Its review finds the arena’s threats unconvincing and the film short on suspense, although it credits Zada with enough charm to sustain interest through much of the running time.
Between those poles sits Variety, which considers the prequel watchable and an improvement over The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, but also thin and slow to move forward. Its criticism centers on how closely the movie retraces the original Hunger Games structure and how long it takes to bring Haymitch’s story home.
Gizmodo likewise finds considerable repetition, but argues that returning fans will get more from its connections and character history. Its review praises Zada’s charisma and highlights the film’s interest in propaganda: what Haymitch experiences and what the Capitol allows its audience to see can be very different things.
The People Behind the Familiar Names

The younger versions of established characters are another major draw. Gizmodo singles out an ensemble that includes Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, and Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, while noting that some recognizable performers have very little screen time.
There’s also a connection to the previous prequel through Whitney Peak’s Lenore Dove Baird. Speaking to GamesRadar+, Peak said Rachel Zegler’s Lucy Gray helped inspire her performance, including through her singing. The outlet identifies Lenore Dove as Lucy Gray’s relative and Haymitch’s girlfriend, giving fans another link across Panem’s timeline.
For anyone planning opening-weekend logistics, /Film reports that there are no mid-credits or post-credits scenes. The outlet confirms that The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens in theaters November 20, 2026.
Noobenheim News for Nerds